never fear, says NYT columnist
Ross Douthat in the NYT writes about the fall of the Berlin Wall and then the Soviet Union.
…Never has liberation come to so many people all at once — to Eastern Europe’s millions, released from decades of bondage; to the world, freed from the shadow of nuclear Armageddon; and to the democratic West, victorious after a century of ideological struggle.
Never has so great a revolution been accomplished so swiftly and so peacefully, by ordinary men and women rather than utopians with guns.
Twenty years later, we still haven’t come to terms with the scope of our deliverance. Francis Fukuyama famously described the post-Communist era as “the end of history.” By this, he didn’t mean the end of events — wars and famines, financial panics and terrorist bombings. He meant the disappearance of any enduring, existential threat to liberal democracy and free-market capitalism.
This thesis has been much contested, but it holds up remarkably well. Even 9/11 didn’t undo the work of ’89. Osama bin Laden is no Hitler, and Islamism isn’t in the same league as the last century’s totalitarianisms. Marxism and fascism seduced the West’s elite; Islamic radicalism seduces men like the Fort Hood shooter. Our enemies resort to terrorism because they’re weak, and because we’re so astonishingly strong.
Yet nobody seems quite willing to believe it. Instead, we keep returning to the idea that liberal society is just as vulnerable as it was before the Berlin Wall came down.
On the right, pundits and politicians have cultivated a persistent cold-war-style alarmism about our foreign enemies — Vladimir Putin one week, Hugo Chavez the next, Kim Jong-il the week after that.
Two points: one need not fear the return of another Soviet empire to be concerned about the security of our nation post 9/11.
Second, civilizations can and have rotted from within. The quickest way is to not reproduce. The Bible should say: “Those with kids will inherit the earth.” Both Europe and Japan are committing suicide via abortion and contraception.
As it stands, Muslims will inherit Europe, and soon. Whether that is a negative depends on if the Muslim majority-to-be becomes moderate and respectful of western values or seeks a return to 13th century values.
On the left, there’s an enduring fascination with the pseudo-Marxist vision of global capitalism as an enormous Ponzi scheme, destined to be undone by peak oil, climate change, or the next financial bubble.
Alas, the left is running our country right now and making policy with that warped vision.
Meanwhile, our domestic politics are shot through with antitotalitarian obsessions, even as real totalitarianism recedes in history’s rear-view mirror. Plenty of liberals were convinced that a vote for George W. Bush was a vote for theocracy or fascism. Too many conservatives are persuaded that Barack Obama’s liberalism is a step removed from Leninism.
Totalitarianism originally described a progressive vision in which the state was responsible for the total welfare of its citizens — cradle to grave. Of course, that meant the state had great authority over its citizens.
Does that not sound familiar?